We need to determine the grades for our course, which - contrary to previous courses we taught - is not a no-brainer. Our students definitely "womaned up", or dropped out, after the initial (somewhat)
rampant copying. (And, we adapted our expectations and homeworks, to be at a level a little bit lower than what we are told is a killer" MIT PhD level course.) Almost everyone will easily pass, and many will get a score of 100, because many students answered bonus questions and even corrected mistakes in recently published papers in prestigious conferences (
WWW 2010).
Unfortunately, however, there is one student who really does not deserve to pass. He has not done anything (in fact, we were not aware of his existence) until the final, which he handed in one hour late (it was a take-home exam), and on which received only 45/100 (if we don't penalize for the late submission, which we would do with any other student). A few weeks later, during the weekend, and a few days before we are supposed to submit the final grades, we received his homework sets, which he himself admits were written "in his own words" after reading other people's answers. Something we explicitly do not allow at all.
Failing him is a no-brainer, but unfortunately, there are complicating circumstances.
He says he says he was not doing well (thinking about having to leave the university, and even suicide) at the beginning of the semester. Only after we told him that he could not pass, did he share this info. We asked the institute for input, and at first they told us that his grade was our decision.
This morning, we were called at 8 in the morning. We were even awake :) We were asked about this student, and about whether he would fail. If he fails another course, he will be kicked out of the university.
I am sure many of you have seen this situation before. Here is a student who we hear is not stupid, but who we have never seen and based on his work, deserves less than 30/100 as an overall grade. He may be suicidal. What should we do/what do you recommend?
I have no clue why they do not teach this in grad school :)